Friday, September 14, 2012

Let's Talk About Santa Clause

Once you begin to settle into a country it can be easy to fall into a sense of false belonging.  You learn your way around the supermarket and the train station and suddenly things don't seem so foreign anymore... until you start talking about Santa Clause.  I'm going to do my best to write this from a non-culturally chauvinistic perspective, so here goes: Unlike the jolly, rotund American Santa Clause who lives in the North Pole, rides a sleigh pulled by reindeer who can fly, and runs a workshop manned by elves, the Dutch Sinterklaas is a rather different story.  Holland begins its Saint Nicholas celebration in late November when Sinterklaas arrives on a steamboat from Spain (where he resides, who woulda thunk it?).  Upon disembarking, Sinterklaas mounts his trusty white steed, Amerigo, (no sleigh for the Dutch Santa)  And he is not alone!  Sinterklaas arrives with several helpers known as Zwarte Pieten (literally translated as black Petes).  These Zwarte Pieten are Dutch men and women who don black face and brightly colored jesteresque costumes and tease the children at the Sinterklaas parade.  Why the incredibly unPC makeup you ask?  Well, the reason for Zwarte Piet's blackness is hotly debated!  Some claim that the Zwarte Pieten were once slaves freed by Sinterklaas. Others argue that they are black from the soot from sliding down chimneys to deliver presents.  But I think my favorite argument for Zwarte Piet's skin color is that Zwarte Piet is the devil, who Sinterklaas conquered and now employs.  Yup.  That's right.  Santa fought the devil.  And won.  And now the devil works for him.  (Isn't Dutch tradition fascinating?)  These days the Zwarte Pieten help Sinterklaas distribute presents and play small tricks on Dutch children.  However, legend has it they used to be a bit more feisty.  The tradition goes that, back in the day, if you misbehaved the Zwarte Pieten would beat you up, or, if you were really bad, they would stuff you in a sack and take you back to Spain!  

So, why were we discussing Sinterklaas and Zwarte Piete during a lecture with a prestigious academic?  The Dutch are currently discussing the acceptability of having a national tradition that is so potentially racially problematic.  In addition to the Zwarte Pieten, it is common for Dutch children to dress up as Zwarte Pieten and don black face for the Sinterklaas parade.  While some Dutch are arguing that this tradition is inherently racist and must be changed, others are calling for the preservation of Dutch tradition.  This debate has yet to be resolved.     

Oh, fun fact: Saint Nicholas is the patron saint of Amsterdam! 

No comments:

Post a Comment